Explore PA’s Top Lake Fishing Spots | Ultimate 2024 Guide

Pennsylvania, known for its lush forests and winding rivers, is also home to some of the most incredible lake fishing opportunities in the United States. With over 4,000 lakes, reservoirs, and ponds scattered throughout the state, anglers of all skill levels can find their perfect fishing spot. From the expansive waters of Lake Erie to the tranquil beauty of Raystown Lake, the Keystone State offers a diverse array of fishing experiences. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take you on a journey through Pennsylvania’s top lake fishing destinations, revealing insider tips, prime fishing spots, and the best times to plan your angling adventure.

1. Lake Erie: A Great Lakes Fishing Paradise

Lake Erie, the fourth-largest of the Great Lakes, offers unparalleled fishing opportunities along Pennsylvania’s shoreline. Known as the “Walleye Capital of the World,” Lake Erie is a must-visit destination for anglers seeking trophy-sized walleye, yellow perch, steelhead, and smallmouth bass.

Prime Fishing Spots:

• Presque Isle Bay in Erie
• The waters off Walnut Creek Access
• The Cribs, a series of underwater reefs

Best Time to Fish: April through October, with peak walleye season from June to September.

Anglers catch an average of 1.5 million fish each year in Presque Isle Bay, Lake Erie, and its tributaries. Popular game fish species to target include:

• Steelhead: Lake Erie and its tributaries provide a world-class steelhead fishery.
• Bass: Smallmouth bass funnel into Presque Isle Bay in the millions every spring to spawn.
• Walleye: The majority of Lake Erie walleye fishing takes place out on the open lake. Peak season is June-September.
• Yellow Perch: Prized for their tasty fillets, yellow perch are abundant and can be caught using minnows or small jigs.

2. Raystown Lake: Scenic Beauty and Diverse Fishing Opportunities

Nestled in the heart of the Allegheny Mountains, Raystown Lake is the largest lake entirely within Pennsylvania’s borders. This 8,300-acre reservoir offers excellent fishing for a variety of species, including striped bass, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, crappie, and lake trout.

Prime Fishing Spots:

• Seven Points Recreation Area
• Susquehannock Campground
• Aitch Access Area

Best Time to Fish: Spring and fall for striped bass, summer months for largemouth and smallmouth bass.

Raystown Lake is arguably the best striped bass lake in Pennsylvania. The PA Fish & Boat Commission stocks over 100,000 striped bass fingerlings here every year. Other notable species include:

• Lake Trout: Populations are maintained through routine stockings by the PA Fish & Boat Commission.
• Walleye: Walleye fishing peaks in spring and fall. Try trolling or jigging in 10-20 ft of water.
• Muskellunge: While elusive, some impressive 40-45 inch muskies are pulled out of Raystown each year.

3. Pymatuning Reservoir: The Musky Capital of Pennsylvania

Straddling the Pennsylvania-Ohio border, Pymatuning Reservoir is a 17,088-acre lake renowned for its exceptional muskellunge (musky) fishing. In addition to muskies, anglers can target walleye, crappie, perch, and catfish in these productive waters.

Prime Fishing Spots:

• Linesville Spillway, famous for its “Where the Ducks Walk on the Fish” attraction
• Espyville Boat Launch
• Ohio/Pennsylvania Causeway

Best Time to Fish: June through October for muskies, spring and fall for walleye.

The 17,088-acre Pymatuning Reservoir is a warmwater fishery. Common species are:

• Muskellunge: Pymatuning is known as the “Musky Capital of PA”. Target them June-October with large lures.
• Walleye: Spring and fall offer the best walleye action. Try trolling crankbaits or drifting with live bait.
• Crappie: Both black and white crappie are abundant. Fish brush piles and stumps in 15+ ft of water.

4. Lake Wallenpaupack: A Pocono Mountains Gem

Situated in the scenic Pocono Mountains, Lake Wallenpaupack is a 5,700-acre reservoir that offers outstanding fishing for smallmouth bass, largemouth bass, striped bass, walleye, and a variety of panfish species.

Prime Fishing Spots:

• Mangan Cove
• Ironwood Point
• Ledgedale Recreation Area

Best Time to Fish: Spring and fall for bass, summer months for panfish.

Lake Wallenpaupack is stocked with striped bass, and some of the best fishing in Pennsylvania is found here. Other notable species include:

• Smallmouth Bass: Rocky points and drop-offs are prime spots. Use tube jigs, crankbaits, and live bait.
• Largemouth Bass: Target weed beds and submerged timber with spinnerbaits, jigs, and soft plastics.
• Walleye: While not as common, walleye fishing can be productive, especially during the cooler months.

5. Presque Isle Bay: Erie’s Hidden Fishing Treasure

Presque Isle Bay, located in Erie, is a 3,200-acre bay that offers excellent fishing opportunities for a wide range of species, including perch, bass, walleye, and steelhead. This protected bay is perfect for both shore and boat fishing.

Prime Fishing Spots:

• Perry Monument
• Horseshoe Pond
• Misery Bay

Best Time to Fish: Spring for perch, fall for steelhead.

It’s hard to argue that any place other than Presque Isle Bay offers the best bass fishing in Pennsylvania. Other notable fishing opportunities include:

• Steelhead: Presque Isle Bay is a surprising winter haunt for Lake Erie steelhead. Try jigging spoons and minnows.
• Perch: Target yellow perch in spring around the bay’s numerous piers, docks, and weed beds.
• Crappie: Both black and white crappie thrive in the bay’s protected waters. Look for them around structure.

6. Fishing License Requirements and Regulations

Before embarking on your Pennsylvania lake fishing adventure, it’s essential to obtain the proper fishing licenses and familiarize yourself with the state’s fishing regulations.

• Fishing Licenses: Anglers aged 16 and older must possess a valid Pennsylvania fishing license. Licenses can be purchased online, at various issuing agents, or at county treasurers’ offices.
• Lake-Specific Regulations: Be sure to check for any lake-specific regulations, such as catch limits, size restrictions, or seasonal closures, before fishing.

Visit the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission website for more information on licenses and regulations.

7. Best Fishing Techniques for Pennsylvania Lakes

To maximize your success on Pennsylvania’s lakes, consider the following fishing techniques:

• Trolling: Slowly dragging lures or baits behind a moving boat is an effective method for targeting walleye, trout, and striped bass.
• Jigging: Vertically fishing with a jig and live bait or soft plastics works well for walleye, perch, and bass.
• Casting: Throwing crankbaits, spinnerbaits, or topwater lures is a great way to cover water and attract active bass and muskies.
• Still Fishing: Suspending live bait, such as minnows or nightcrawlers, under a bobber is a simple yet effective technique for panfish and trout.

8. Recommended Fishing Gear and Equipment

Having the right gear can make all the difference in your fishing success. Consider investing in the following:

• Rods and Reels: Medium to medium-heavy spinning or baitcasting combos for bass, walleye, and muskies; light to medium spinning gear for panfish and trout.
• Line: Monofilament or fluorocarbon line in the 6-12 lb range for most species; heavier braided line for muskies.
• Lures: A variety of crankbaits, spinnerbaits, jigs, and soft plastics to match the forage base in each lake.
• Live Bait: Minnows, nightcrawlers, and leeches are popular choices for many species.
• Electronics: A fish finder or GPS unit can help locate productive fishing spots and structure.

9. Hiring a Fishing Guide or Charter Service

If you’re new to fishing or unfamiliar with a particular lake, consider hiring a local fishing guide or charter service. Experienced guides can provide valuable knowledge, techniques, and equipment to help you make the most of your fishing trip.

Some reputable guide services include:

• Reel Escape Fishing Charters (Lake Erie)
• Raystown Striper Guide Service (Raystown Lake)
• Pymatuning Fishing Charters (Pymatuning Reservoir)

10. Conclusion: Embark on Your Pennsylvania Lake Fishing Adventure

With its diverse array of lakes and abundant fishing opportunities, Pennsylvania is a true angler’s paradise. From the world-class walleye fishery of Lake Erie to the scenic beauty of Raystown Lake and the musky-filled waters of Pymatuning Reservoir, the Keystone State offers unforgettable fishing experiences for all.

So, grab your gear, secure your fishing license, and set out to explore the incredible lake fishing hotspots Pennsylvania has to offer. With this ultimate guide at your fingertips, you’ll be well-prepared to create lasting memories and reel in the catch of a lifetime on your next Pennsylvania lake fishing adventure.

For more information on Pennsylvania’s fishing destinations, regulations, and tips, visit the official Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission website.